Korean Seolleongtang

  • Why Americans Are Driving Across Town for Korean Seolleongtang

    After a long day, sometimes you don’t want another burger.

    You don’t want fried chicken.

    You don’t want pizza covered in cheese.

    You don’t even want something exciting.

    You just want something warm.

    That may help explain why some Americans are discovering one of Korea’s least flashy but most comforting foods:

    Seolleongtang (설렁탕).

    In places like Los Angeles, people can drive across town to Koreatown for a steaming bowl of Korean beef soup.

    Some restaurants specializing in Korean soups have traditionally served late-night diners, and seolleongtang has long been associated with breakfast, hangovers, cold weather and those days when your body simply doesn’t feel right.

    Eater Los Angeles, for example, recommends seolleongtang as a Korean breakfast and describes it as especially restorative for people recovering from a hangover or nursing a cold.

    But to understand why this simple-looking soup can inspire such loyalty, you have to understand what seolleongtang means in Korea.

    Because for many Koreans, it isn’t merely soup.

    It is the kind of food you eat when your body needs a little help getting through the day.


    What Is Korean Seolleongtang?

    Seolleongtang is a traditional Korean soup made by slowly simmering beef bones and meat.

    The long cooking process extracts flavor and richness from the bones and beef, often creating the pale, cloudy broth many people associate with the dish.

    But not every seolleongtang looks exactly the same.

    Some restaurants prefer a milky-white broth with a stronger bone flavor.

    Others produce a clearer broth with more emphasis on the clean flavor of beef.

    MICHELIN describes seolleongtang as one of Korea’s quintessential soul foods and notes that preparation varies considerably from restaurant to restaurant.

    The bowl itself can look surprisingly plain.

    Beef.

    Broth.

    Rice.

    Sometimes thin noodles.

    Green onions.

    Salt and pepper.

    That’s about it.

    And that’s exactly why making truly great seolleongtang is harder than it looks.


    In Korea, Seolleongtang Feels Like an Early Morning

    Ask a Korean what image comes to mind when thinking about seolleongtang, and many answers will have less to do with fine dining than with everyday life.

    For me, one of the strongest images is early morning.

    It is still cold outside.

    The city hasn’t completely woken up.

    Someone who has to start work early pushes open the door of a small restaurant.

    He is hungry.

    A long day is waiting for him.

    Then a black earthenware bowl arrives at the table.

    The broth is still bubbling.

    Steam rises toward his face.

    He adds some chopped green onions, a little salt and perhaps some black pepper.

    Then he puts rice into the soup.

    One spoonful.

    Then another.

    Gradually, the cold disappears.

    The stomach becomes full.

    And somehow the day feels a little more manageable.

    That is the emotional image of seolleongtang that is difficult to explain with the English words “beef bone soup.”

    Technically, that description may be useful.

    Emotionally, it doesn’t come close.


    A Food Koreans Turn to When They Don’t Feel Well

    Seolleongtang also has a strong reputation in Korea as nourishing food.

    When someone feels weak, catches a cold or simply feels exhausted, a hot bowl of soup is often appealing.

    That doesn’t mean seolleongtang should be considered medicine.

    It isn’t.

    But culturally, it occupies a similar emotional space to chicken soup in parts of the United States.

    Warm. Familiar. Gentle. Restorative.

    And something interesting is happening in America.

    People are beginning to experience it in much the same way.

    Eater Los Angeles recently featured a bowl of seolleongtang eaten just before the writer came down with a summer cold, describing the soup’s warmth and rich texture as deeply soothing.

    That’s fascinating to me.

    The person eating the soup may have changed.

    The country has changed.

    But the emotional purpose of the food remains remarkably similar.


    The Secret Partner Isn’t Another Meat Dish

    If you order seolleongtang for the first time, there is one thing you shouldn’t ignore.

    Kkakdugi (깍두기).

    Kkakdugi is Korean radish kimchi, usually cut into cubes and fermented with chili pepper, garlic and other seasonings.

    A spoonful of rich, mild broth followed by a crunchy, slightly sour and spicy piece of kkakdugi creates one of those combinations that makes much more sense after you taste it.

    The broth calms the kimchi.

    The kimchi wakes up the broth.

    This isn’t a side dish placed on the table merely because Korean restaurants serve lots of side dishes.

    Kkakdugi is part of the seolleongtang experience.

    MICHELIN’s discussion of the dish makes the same point: kimchi, especially kkakdugi, cuts through the richness of the beef broth, and famous seolleongtang restaurants often take their kimchi extremely seriously.

    Some Koreans even add a little kkakdugi juice to their soup.

    For someone tasting seolleongtang for the first time, that may sound strange.

    Try the original broth first.

    Then try it with kkakdugi.

    You’ll understand.


    The Best Way to Eat Seolleongtang

    There isn’t one mandatory method.

    But this is how I would introduce it to someone eating Korean seolleongtang for the first time.

    First, taste the broth before seasoning it.

    Good seolleongtang is often intentionally served lightly seasoned so each diner can adjust it.

    Then add a little salt.

    Add black pepper if you like it.

    Add plenty of chopped green onions.

    Taste again.

    Now take a bite of beef.

    Then kkakdugi.

    Once you’ve tasted the broth on its own, add some rice.

    Don’t necessarily throw everything in immediately.

    Add a little rice at a time and see how the texture changes.

    Soon you are no longer eating soup and rice separately.

    You are eating gukbap (국밥) — one of the most comforting forms of Korean everyday food.


    And Then Comes Dolsotbap

    There is an even better combination found at some Korean restaurants:

    Seolleongtang with dolsotbap (돌솥밥).

    Dolsotbap means rice cooked and served in a hot stone pot.

    When the lid is opened, steam rises from freshly cooked rice.

    The rice is hot, glossy and fragrant.

    You scoop it out.

    Then put some into your seolleongtang.

    Hot rice.

    Hot beef broth.

    Tender beef.

    And one crunchy piece of kkakdugi.

    But here is the part many first-time visitors don’t expect.

    Don’t take away the empty stone pot.

    The meal isn’t finished.


    Wait — Why Are Koreans Pouring Hot Water Into the Rice Pot?

    After the rice is removed, a thin layer remains stuck to the scorching-hot bottom of the stone pot.

    This is nurungji (누룽지) — toasted, scorched rice.

    Pour hot water into the pot.

    Put the lid back on.

    Then continue eating your seolleongtang.

    By the time you finish the soup, return to the stone pot.

    The toasted rice has softened and infused the water with a subtle roasted-rice flavor.

    Depending on how it is prepared and described, this final rice-water experience is closely associated with sungnyung (숭늉).

    Now you have one last warm, clean-tasting finish to the meal.

    So a meal that initially looked like nothing more than beef soup has become:

    Seolleongtang → Rice → Kkakdugi → Nurungji/Sungnyung

    That’s one reason Korean food can be difficult to understand from a menu photograph.

    Sometimes the experience isn’t one dish.

    It’s the sequence in which you eat it.


    Seolleongtang Looks Easy. It Isn’t.

    This may be the most important thing to understand about seolleongtang.

    It looks simple.

    And simple food can be incredibly difficult to make well.

    A spicy sauce can sometimes hide imperfections.

    Strong seasoning can dominate other flavors.

    Seolleongtang has nowhere to hide.

    The quality of the bones and meat matters.

    How the broth is simmered matters.

    How fat is managed matters.

    How the meat is cooked matters.

    And above all:

    time matters.

    One of Seoul’s oldest famous seolleongtang restaurants, Imun Seolnongtang, has historically simmered its broth for more than 17 hours, according to MICHELIN’s feature on the dish.

    Mapo Ok, another long-running Seoul specialist, is described by MICHELIN as slowly boiling beef and ox bones to produce its signature broth. The restaurant dates to 1949.

    There is no dramatic moment when the dish suddenly becomes great.

    It happens slowly.

    Hour after hour.

    Perhaps that’s part of its character.


    Why Seolleongtang Works So Well in America

    American food culture isn’t lacking in soup.

    Chicken noodle soup already plays an important comfort-food role.

    There are regional stews, chowders and countless immigrant soup traditions.

    So why might seolleongtang connect with American diners?

    I think the answer is surprisingly simple.

    You don’t need to understand Korean culture to understand being tired.

    You don’t need to speak Korean to know what it feels like to come home after a terrible day.

    You don’t need to know the history of gukbap to appreciate holding a spoon over a steaming bowl on a cold morning.

    And you don’t need to grow up eating kkakdugi to discover that its sharp fermented flavor is wonderful with a mild beef broth.

    That universality may be one of seolleongtang’s greatest strengths.

    It doesn’t demand attention.

    It doesn’t explode with spice.

    It doesn’t need melted cheese, an enormous portion or a dramatic tableside presentation to impress you.

    It simply makes you feel better.


    From Seoul Before Sunrise to Los Angeles After Midnight

    There is something beautiful about how food travels.

    In Seoul, I think of a worker eating seolleongtang early in the morning before starting a long day.

    In Los Angeles, someone may seek out the same soup after a long day, during a cold, or when they simply want something warm and familiar.

    Koreatown’s long-running Han Bat has become particularly associated with seolleongtang, with Eater describing generations of the same family slowly simmering ox bones for the restaurant’s broth.

    Different city.

    Different customers.

    Different lives.

    But perhaps the reason they lift that first spoonful isn’t so different.


    The Korean Comfort Food That Doesn’t Need to Shout

    Korean food has become famous around the world for powerful flavors.

    Korean fried chicken.

    Tteokbokki.

    Buldak.

    Korean barbecue.

    They are exciting, colorful and easy to show in a short video.

    Seolleongtang is almost the opposite.

    White broth.

    White rice.

    A few pieces of beef.

    Green onions.

    Kkakdugi on the side.

    It isn’t particularly Instagrammable.

    But perhaps that is exactly the point.

    Seolleongtang isn’t food that asks you to look at it.

    It’s food that asks you to sit down.

    To warm your hands.

    To add some rice.

    To eat a piece of kkakdugi.

    And to forget, for twenty minutes, how tiring the day has been.


    Sometimes We Don’t Need Exciting Food

    Seolleongtang looks simple.

    But simple Korean food is often the hardest to make.

    There is nowhere for bad ingredients to hide.

    No powerful sauce needs to cover the broth.

    What creates its depth isn’t a secret seasoning.

    It is time.

    Maybe that’s also why a bowl of seolleongtang can feel so comforting after a long day.

    The person eating it might be in Seoul before sunrise.

    Or driving across Los Angeles looking for Korean soup late at night.

    The place has changed.

    The language has changed.

    But the reason for eating it may not have changed very much.

    Sometimes, after a difficult day, what we want most isn’t exciting food.

    We just want something warm.

    And sometimes, that’s enough.


    What About You?

    Have you ever tried seolleongtang?

    Would you choose a mild Korean beef soup over spicy Korean food after a long, exhausting day?

    And if you try it, don’t forget the kkakdugi.

    It might completely change the bowl.